As a manager of people, you craft assumptions based on what you believe and what you value. You observe and absorb expectations that have been communicated, intentionally or unintentionally. You can end up making decisions based on an unexamined
foundation. The results can range from inconvenient to dire.
The road to heck is paved with good intentions.
For instance, it might seem like the right thing to do to fight for a high performance rating for all your employees. Then your
peers pushes back that Sally isn't pulling her weight. How do you tell her she has performance improvement needs without her asking why she's just now hearing this? After all, just a few months ago, via her performance rating, you told her she was meeting expectations. You communicated some version of, "Just keep doing what you're doing."
Now you're in a fix. Do you endure the prospect of
losing the respect of your team members or the discomfort of telling Sally the truth, or both? Don't overlook the difficult position that you've put the organization in. If Sally's performance doesn't improve she must be held accountable to that. Your employer may have to support your decisions in litigation, if worse comes to worst. Good intentions can sometimes backfire, in great and small ways.
How do you sort through the seemingly conflicting expectations of you, as a manager of people?
As a manager, you have your own natural inclination in response to a situation. When I say natural inclination, what I mean is, what occurs to you first. You may not consider your first reaction reasonable or actionable. What
I know is that your natural inclination should not just be tossed away, and often holds a clue to a wise, powerful response —even your superpower! When I coach managers, I like to start there. Then we dial in other areas.
I focus on these 3 domains: